Skip to content
ADVERTISEMENT
Sign In
  • Sections
    • News
    • Advice
    • The Review
  • Topics
    • Data
    • Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
    • Finance & Operations
    • International
    • Leadership & Governance
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Scholarship & Research
    • Student Success
    • Technology
    • Transitions
    • The Workplace
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Special Issues
    • Podcast: College Matters from The Chronicle
  • Newsletters
  • Events
    • Virtual Events
    • Chronicle On-The-Road
    • Professional Development
  • Ask Chron
  • Store
    • Featured Products
    • Reports
    • Data
    • Collections
    • Back Issues
  • Jobs
    • Find a Job
    • Post a Job
    • Professional Development
    • Career Resources
    • Virtual Career Fair
  • More
  • Sections
    • News
    • Advice
    • The Review
  • Topics
    • Data
    • Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
    • Finance & Operations
    • International
    • Leadership & Governance
    • Teaching & Learning
    • Scholarship & Research
    • Student Success
    • Technology
    • Transitions
    • The Workplace
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Special Issues
    • Podcast: College Matters from The Chronicle
  • Newsletters
  • Events
    • Virtual Events
    • Chronicle On-The-Road
    • Professional Development
  • Ask Chron
  • Store
    • Featured Products
    • Reports
    • Data
    • Collections
    • Back Issues
  • Jobs
    • Find a Job
    • Post a Job
    • Professional Development
    • Career Resources
    • Virtual Career Fair
    Upcoming Events:
    College Advising
    Serving Higher Ed
    Chronicle Festival 2025
Sign In
Technology

Publishers and Library Groups Spar in Appeal to Ruling on Electronic Course Reserves

By Jennifer Howard February 1, 2013

Fair use and electronic course reserves are back in court. A keenly watched copyright case that pitted three academic publishers against Georgia State University has entered the appeals phase, with a flurry of filings and motions this week and more expected soon.

To continue reading for FREE, please sign in.

Sign In

Or subscribe now to read with unlimited access for as low as $10/month.

Don’t have an account? Sign up now.

A free account provides you access to a limited number of free articles each month, plus newsletters, job postings, salary data, and exclusive store discounts.

Sign Up

Fair use and electronic course reserves are back in court. A keenly watched copyright case that pitted three academic publishers against Georgia State University has entered the appeals phase, with a flurry of filings and motions this week and more expected soon.

One surprise motion came from the U.S. Department of Justice, which requested more time to consider filing an amicus brief either in support of the publishers or in support of neither party. The possibility that the government might weigh in triggered speculation and anxiety among some observers, including academic librarians worried that the Justice Department could sabotage educational fair use if it sides with the publishers against the university. A spokesman for the department told The Chronicle it had no comment at this time.

The case in question is Cambridge U. Press et al. v. Mark P. Becker et al. In 2008, Cambridge, Oxford University Press, and SAGE Publishers sued Georgia State, asserting it had committed widespread copyright violations when it allowed some of their content to be used, unlicensed, in e-reserves. The Association of American Publishers and the Copyright Clearance Center, which specializes in licensing content to universities, bankrolled the legal action.

Last May the presiding judge, Orinda Evans of the U.S. District Court in Atlanta, handed the university a significant victory in the case. Judge Evans ruled that Georgia State had committed copyright violations in only five of the 99 instances the publishers put forward, and she ordered the plaintiffs to pay the defendants’ legal costs. Fair-use advocates mostly celebrated the judge’s verdict.

The publishers decided to appeal. The case will be heard by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit, which is no stranger to high-profile copyright cases. In 2001 it heard a dispute between the estate of Margaret Mitchell and the publisher of The Wind Done Gone, a novel by Alice Randall that parodied Mitchell’s Gone With the Wind. The court vacated an injunction against the publisher, and the estate dropped the lawsuit in exchange for certain concessions.

In their brief, filed on Monday, the publishers argue that, if the lower court’s ruling stands, it will have implications that go far beyond Georgia State’s practices. The publishers play up the idea that e-reserves amount to course packs or anthologies of reading material. Judge Evans’s decision “invites universities nationwide to accelerate the migration of course-pack creation from paper to electronic format” and to sidestep legal permission to use copyrighted content, the brief states.

That pattern of behavior could undercut “the efficient licensing markets that have evolved to serve the needs of academic users.” That, in turn, “would threaten the ongoing ability of academic publishers to continue to create works of scholarship,” the publishers argue.

The Association of American University Presses plans to file an amicus brief on behalf of publishers on Monday, February 4. The Chronicle saw an advance copy of the brief. In it, the association argues that the outcome of the case will directly affect its members, who publish much of the content professors use in their courses.

The brief echoes Cambridge, Oxford, and SAGE’s concerns that the spread of e-reserves means more uncompensated use of copyrighted works and leads to smaller permissions revenues. The association notes the importance of the fair-use doctrine in encouraging research and scholarship. What’s objectionable, it says, is using large amounts of in-copyright material without paying for it.

Not an ‘Existential Threat’

But Brandon Butler, director of public-policy initiatives for the Association of Research Libraries, took issue with the argument that e-reserves put publishers at great risk.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I’m baffled that the publishers continue to claim that course reserves pose some kind of existential threat to their business,” he told The Chronicle via e-mail. “It was established at trial that GSU’s practices are in the mainstream, so libraries are basically already doing what the publishers claim will put them out of business, and yet Oxford University Press reported $1-billion in sales last year, $180-million in profits. Is that what a publisher on the verge of collapse looks like?”

Mr. Butler’s group belongs to the Library Copyright Alliance, along with the American Library Association and the Association of College and Research Libraries. The alliance has supported Georgia State throughout and expects to file an amicus brief on its behalf no later than March.

Georgia State University has not yet filed its brief in the appeal, and a representative of the university said it had no comment now. Filings on the publishers’ side were originally due on February 4. The Justice Department’s request asks the court to extend that deadline.

Librarians who track copyright and intellectual-property issues are paying close attention to the appeal. The possibility that the government might side with the publishers has them concerned.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I think a lot of faculty and researchers will be shocked to hear that the U.S. government might actually weigh in on the side of publishers instead of its public universities,” said Katie Fortney, copyright-management officer at the University of California’s California Digital Library. “The district court’s opinion was thorough and well reasoned, and I would hope and expect that the 11th Circuit will also decide in favor of fair use, whatever the DOJ decides to file. They really ought to be filing an amicus brief in support of Georgia State.”

Ms. Fortney has heard a lot of course-pack jokes—a nod to the publishers’ brief—from fellow copyright librarians in the last day or so. The humor belies what’s at stake.

Librarians take copyright seriously and “were really heartened by the Georgia State case, just to see a court case come out that supports the kind of educational fair use that we’ve all been doing,” she said.

“We’re public universities, many of us, educating the nation’s youth,” Ms. Fortney added. “We feel like we’re fulfilling our mission. I think people would just be crushed and confused to see the administration come out and say we are not.”

We welcome your thoughts and questions about this article. Please email the editors or submit a letter for publication.
Tags
Technology Libraries
Share
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Email
About the Author
Jennifer Howard
Jennifer Howard, who began writing for The Chronicle in 2005, covered publishing, scholarly communication, libraries, archives, digital humanities, humanities research, and technology.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Content

Long-Awaited Ruling in Copyright Case Mostly Favors Georgia State U.
What’s at Stake in the Georgia State Copyright Case
Hot Type: Publishers Say They Are Not the Enemy in University Copyright Disputes

More News

Vector illustration of large open scissors  with several workers in seats dangling by white lines
Iced Out
Duke Administrators Accused of Bypassing Shared-Governance Process in Offering Buyouts
Illustration showing money being funnelled into the top of a microscope.
'A New Era'
Higher-Ed Associations Pitch an Alternative to Trump’s Cap on Research Funding
Illustration showing classical columns of various heights, each turning into a stack of coins
Endowment funds
The Nation’s Wealthiest Small Colleges Just Won a Big Tax Exemption
WASHINGTON, DISTICT OF COLUMBIA, UNITED STATES - 2025/04/14: A Pro-Palestinian demonstrator holding a sign with Release Mahmud Khalil written on it, stands in front of the ICE building while joining in a protest. Pro-Palestinian demonstrators rally in front of the ICE building, demanding freedom for Mahmoud Khalil and all those targeted for speaking out against genocide in Palestine. Protesters demand an end to U.S. complicity and solidarity with the resistance in Gaza. (Photo by Probal Rashid/LightRocket via Getty Images)
Campus Activism
An Anonymous Group’s List of Purported Critics of Israel Helped Steer a U.S. Crackdown on Student Activists

From The Review

John T. Scopes as he stood before the judges stand and was sentenced, July 2025.
The Review | Essay
100 Years Ago, the Scopes Monkey Trial Discovered Academic Freedom
By John K. Wilson
Vector illustration of a suited man with a pair of scissors for a tie and an American flag button on his lapel.
The Review | Opinion
A Damaging Endowment Tax Crosses the Finish Line
By Phillip Levine
University of Virginia President Jim Ryan keeps his emotions in check during a news conference, Monday, Nov. 14, 2022 in Charlottesville. Va. Authorities say three people have been killed and two others were wounded in a shooting at the University of Virginia and a student is in custody. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
The Review | Opinion
Jim Ryan’s Resignation Is a Warning
By Robert Zaretsky

Upcoming Events

07-31-Turbulent-Workday_assets v2_Plain.png
Keeping Your Institution Moving Forward in Turbulent Times
Ascendium_Housing_Plain.png
What It Really Takes to Serve Students’ Basic Needs: Housing
Lead With Insight
  • Explore Content
    • Latest News
    • Newsletters
    • Letters
    • Free Reports and Guides
    • Professional Development
    • Events
    • Chronicle Store
    • Chronicle Intelligence
    • Jobs in Higher Education
    • Post a Job
  • Know The Chronicle
    • About Us
    • Vision, Mission, Values
    • DEI at The Chronicle
    • Write for Us
    • Work at The Chronicle
    • Our Reporting Process
    • Advertise With Us
    • Brand Studio
    • Accessibility Statement
  • Account and Access
    • Manage Your Account
    • Manage Newsletters
    • Individual Subscriptions
    • Group and Institutional Access
    • Subscription & Account FAQ
  • Get Support
    • Contact Us
    • Reprints & Permissions
    • User Agreement
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • California Privacy Policy
    • Do Not Sell My Personal Information
1255 23rd Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20037
© 2025 The Chronicle of Higher Education
The Chronicle of Higher Education is academe’s most trusted resource for independent journalism, career development, and forward-looking intelligence. Our readers lead, teach, learn, and innovate with insights from The Chronicle.
Follow Us
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • facebook
  • linkedin