Forget Lonelygirl15, YouTube’s 2006 online video phenom. Professors are the latest YouTube stars. The popularity of their appearances on YouTube and other video-sharing sites may end up opening up the classroom and making teaching — which once took place behind closed doors — a more public art.
What’s more, Web video opens a new form of public intellectualism to scholars looking to participate in an increasingly visual culture.
One Web site that made its debut this month, Big Think, hopes to be “a YouTube for ideas.” The site offers interviews with academics, authors, politicians, and other thinkers. Most of them are filmed in front of a white background, and the interviews are chopped into bite-sized pieces of just a few minutes each. The short clips could have been served up as text quotes, but Victoria R.M. Brown, a founder of Big Think, says video is more engaging. “People like to learn and be informed of things by looking and watching and learning,” she says.
YouTube itself wants to be a venue for academe. In the past few months, several colleges have signed agreements with the site to set up official “channels.” The University of California at Berkeley was the first, and the University of Southern California, the University of New South Wales, in Australia, and Vanderbilt University soon followed.
It remains an open question just how large the audience for talking eggheads is. After all, in the early days of television, many academics hoped to use the medium to beam courses to living rooms, with series like CBS’s Sunrise Semester, which began in 1957. Those efforts are now a distant memory.
Things may be different now, though, since the Internet offers a chance to connect people with the professors and topics that most interest them.
Even YouTube was surprised by how popular the colleges’ content has been, says Adam Hochman, a product manager at Berkeley’s Learning Systems Group. Lectures are long, but most popular YouTube videos run just a few minutes. Lonelygirl15, the “diary” of a teenage girl, had episodes that finished in well under a minute. Many other popular shorts involve cute animals or juvenile stunts.
Yet some lectures on Berkeley’s channel scored 100,000 viewers each, and people were sitting through the whole talks. “Professors in a sense are rock stars,” Mr. Hochman concludes. “We’re getting as many hits as you would find with some of the big media players.”
YouTube officials say they weren’t surprised by the buzz, and they say more colleges are coming forward. “We expect that education will be a vibrant category on YouTube,” says Obadiah Greenberg, the site’s strategic-partner manager, in an e-mail interview. “Everybody loves to learn.”
Not Always Easy to Find
To set up an official channel on YouTube, colleges sign an agreement allowing them to brand their section of the site by including a logo or school colors, and to upload longer videos than typical users are allowed. No money changes hands in the deals.
But the company hasn’t exactly made it easy to find the academic offerings. Clicking on the education category shows a mix of videos, including some on the lectures of Socrates and others with women posing in lingerie. But that could change if the company begins to sign up more colleges and pay more attention to whether videos are appearing in the correct subject areas, says Dan Colman, director and associate dean of Stanford University’s continuing-studies program, who runs a blog that tracks podcasts and videos made by colleges and professors.
In many cases, colleges were already offering lecture videos on their own Web sites or on Apple’s iTunes U, an educational section of the iTunes Store. But college officials say teaming up with YouTube is expanding their audiences because so many people are poking around the site already.
“It’s one thing to try to invite people to your own site; it’s another thing to be riding the YouTube train,” says Michael J. Schoenfeld, vice chancellor for public affairs at Vanderbilt, where page views shot up after the university’s videos hit YouTube.
T. Mills Kelly, an associate professor of history and art history at George Mason University, says the Web-video trend brings a welcome check on the teaching process. “It introduces a certain level of accountability for what happens in the classroom,” he argued on a recent episode of the university’s Digital Campus podcast.
When professors have their lectures recorded, whether for an audio podcast or a streaming video, it can improve their quality, says Mr. Colman. “Anytime someone knows they’re being taped, they’ll make sure they’re giving a fairly refined lecture, and that certainly can only help,” he says.
It remains to be seen, however, whether videos will lead colleges to weigh teaching more heavily in the tenure and promotion process.
One of the Internet stars at Berkeley is Marian C. Diamond, a professor of anatomy and neuroscience who has taught for more than 40 years. Since the university started uploading her lectures to YouTube, she has been getting fan e-mail from around the world.
A woman in New York City wrote to say that she downloads the lectures and watches them while commuting on the subway; a fitness student in Australia uses them to supplement the college anatomy class he is struggling with; a high-school student in the United Arab Emirates watches because he hopes to one day become a doctor.
“I respond to every one of them,” Ms. Diamond says of the messages. That means more work, but she has no complaints: “For a teacher, you couldn’t ask for anything better.”
New Players
YouTube isn’t the only game in town for educational videos, of course. Besides Big Think, which boasts as an investor Lawrence H. Summers, a former president of Harvard University and a former U.S. secretary of the treasury, there is also FORA.tv. That site, which calls itself “the thinking man’s YouTube,” streams lectures and debates featuring noted scholars and intellectuals. (Think a hipper, Web-based version of C-Span.)
FORA.tv recently started forming partnerships with colleges and universities to offer recordings of campus talks. So far about a dozen colleges — including American University, Berkeley, and the New School — participate. Brian Gruber, founder and chief executive of FORA.tv, says the site’s audience is a quarter of a million viewers per month and is growing at a rate of 20 percent per month.
On their own, a few professors have also tried to craft Web videos that will appeal to a popular online audience.
Two professors at the University of Minnesota-Twin Cities created a 3-D animation explaining a mathematical concept, and attracted more than one million views on YouTube. And Michael L. Wesch, an assistant professor of cultural anthropology at Kansas State University, made a video about Web 2.0 that drew more than 400,000 views. Web video offers a new way for scholars to communicate, he says, noting that he wrote a scholarly article about the same ideas he put in his video, but that the article might be read by only a small number of scholars.
“It’s easier than people think,” Mr. Wesch says of making online videos. “The thought process is very different, which I actually think can be very valuable. I mean, we think a lot about how to present our work in writing, and I think when you shift into thinking about how to present this work visually, it actually forces you to think through things in new ways.”
http://chronicle.com Section: Information Technology Volume 54, Issue 20, Page A19
