Good morning, and welcome to Monday, October 16. Rick Seltzer wrote today’s Briefing. Julia Piper compiled Comings and Goings. Get in touch: rick.seltzer@chronicle.com.
Can the center hold?
Divisions over Israel and Palestine strained many U.S. campuses last week, the first after Hamas, in a surprise attack, killed Israeli civilians and took hostages. But with an Israeli counteroffensive expected to claim more innocent lives in Gaza, this is going to continue to be a major issue for colleges.
Campuses largely made it through last week’s planned protests peacefully. Shouting matches, scuffles, and a few clashes didn’t escalate into widespread violence.
But several developments at the end of the week suggest rising tensions threaten any new equilibrium. Among them:
- An instructor allegedly targeted Jewish students in a Stanford University course. Students reported the instructor, who was teaching a required undergraduate course, asked Jewish students to raise their hands and separated them, calling it a simulation of what’s being done to Palestinians. The lecturer also reportedly asked students about their ancestry and labeled each as “colonizer” or “colonized.” Stanford removed the instructor and is investigating.
- A college president’s comments prompted pro-Palestinian protesters to cancel a rally planned for Thursday at the University of Arizona. The Students for Justice in Palestine chapter said that Robert C. Robbins had made its members feel it wouldn’t be safe to host their event on campus. The president issued a Wednesday statement saying that SJP didn’t speak for the university but that its members had a right to express their views in a safe environment, even though the national organization had made statements endorsing the actions of Hamas that are “antithetical to our university’s values.”
- A petition sought to oust a pro-Palestinian professor at Yale. The petition, which cited a series of social-media posts by the professor that said “Palestinians have every right to resist through armed struggle,” received tens of thousands of signatures. A Yale spokesperson said that the institution is committed to freedom of expression and that the posts represent the professor’s own views. A clinical fellow at the university’s medical school was killed by the Hamas attacks in Israel, the Yale Daily News reported.
- New College of Florida preened and saber-rattled. The public institution posted a reminder that Florida law makes it a felony for anyone to provide material support to terrorist organizations, including Hamas. “Any individual or group at New College providing support or resources to designated foreign terrorist organizations will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law,” it said.
Don’t dismiss those as isolated incidents. Each has specific context, to be sure. But they’re part of a larger cycle of coarsening dialogue and heedless escalation.
The cycle threatens to undercut colleges’ missions as educational settings unless it’s interrupted or taps itself out. Learning can’t happen if students, faculty members, and administrators are unable to interact with one another respectfully.
The big questions: Did last week mark peak tensions on campuses, or will shouting matches continue to escalate as fighting continues in the Middle East? Do any higher-ed leaders have the vision, authority, and relationships on campus to push constituencies out of self-destructive cycles — to suggest that just because groups have the right to posture cruelly as people die, it doesn’t mean they should?